Authored by Zubair Durrani*,
Abstract
Objective: To measure the frequency of perineural invasion in oral squamous cell carcinoma, to correlate its presence with various variables and to assess its impact upon prognosis.
Design: A retrospective analytical study was planned.
Place and Duration of study: Patients were identified with oral squamous cell carcinoma who had underwent surgical excision over the past 7 years in Rehman Medical institute. The duration of the study was 6 months.
Methodology: Pathology reports were collected; and based upon the presence or absence of PNI, Patients were divided in to two groups. The group with PNI were analyzed for a set of associations and then compared with other group for comparison. PNI frequency was correlated with age, gender, site, size and differentiation of tumor. Presence of PNI, number of tumor foci along the perineural region and the size of nerve involved were then correlated with presence or absence with nodal disease and frequency of recurrence in these cases. Results were compiled and statistically analyzed using chi square test.
Results: Total number of Patients included in study were 59. PNI was found present in 13 (22.03%) patients. PNI was found mainly in middle age group. Gender distribution: male-7, female-6 (p=0.454); Site distribution; Tongue carcinoma-6, other sites-7 (p=0.618); Size: T3-10, T1-3 (p=0.330); Differentiation: well differentiated-10, Moderate Differentiated-3 (p=0.197). Association of nodal status with PNI found positive in 6 patients (p=0.000). Association of recurrence with PNI was also found positive in 6 patients (p=0.001). Number of foci of perineural invasions (1 focus-7, 11 foci-1, 3 foci-3, 4 foci-1, 5 foci-1) association with recurrence (6 cases) p=0.535 and lymph node metastasis (6 cases) p=0.490. Nerve size involved by PNI (<1mm-3, >1mm-10) association with either lymph node metastasis (6) p=0.672 or recurrence in the neck (6) p=0.417.
Conclusion: The frequency of PNI was 22.03%. Statistically, no significant association was found between PNI and age, gender, site, grade of tumor and size of the tumor. Significant Association was found in this study between occurrence of PNI with Lymph Node metastasis and Neck Recurrence. No Significant Association was found between number of foci of Perineural invasions or the size of the nerve involved with either lymph node metastasis or recurrence.
Keywords: Perineural invasion; Oral squamous cell carcinoma; Prognostic factors
Introduction
Cancer of the oral cavity is a widely prevalent disease and has been listed as the sixth most common cancer worldwide [1]. Squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) accounts for about 90% of all these cases [2]. Despite tremendous research over the last 70 years, the overall prognosis remains at 50% with no gender difference [3]. The incidence, however, is higher in men than women according to WHO data. Prognostic factors include tumor stage, grade, depth of invasion and lymph node involvement. One of the factors which has a prognostic significance but less well studied is perineural invasion (PNI). The aim of this study was to measure the frequency of PNI in our set of oral squamous cell carcinoma patients. Various variables including age, gender, site, size, grade of the tumor was correlated with PNI for their impact upon its incidence. The presence of PNI, size of the nerve involved and tumor focality were then studied for its relation with nodal metastasis and loco-regional recurrence.
Methodology
A retrospective analytical study was planned. Patients were identified with oral squamous cell carcinoma that had undergone surgical resection over the past 7 years in Rehman Medical institute. Pathology reports were collected, and based upon the presence or absence of PNI, Patients were divided into two groups. The group with PNI were analyzed for a set of associations mentioned above. Presence of PNI, number of tumor foci along the perineural region and the size of nerve involved by PNI were then correlated with presence or absence with nodal disease and frequency of recurrence in these cases. Results were compiled and statistically analyzed using chi square test.
Results
Total number of Patients operated for oral squamous cell carcinoma were 59. PNI was found to be present in 13 (22.03%) patients. Overall age range for all SCC patients was from 28 to 89 (Figure 1) while SCC with PNI were found between 28 to 75 years of age with mean of 48.2 and median of 46 respectively (Figure 2). Out of 13 patients with PNI, there were seven males and six females effected. Tongue was the most common site of presentation with 6 patients followed by Maxillary and mandibular alveolar gingiva effecting two patients each. There was a single presentation each for lip, buccal mucosa and neck (unknown primary). Three patients had presented with T1 and ten with T3 size. Ten patients were well differentiated while three were moderately differentiated. The patient’s characteristics and pathologic findings are summarized in (Table 1).
Table 1:
Table 2:
Six patients of PNI presented with pathologically involved lymph nodes. This association between PNI and lymph node involvement by tumor was found to be statistically significant on Pearson chi-square test (p=0.000). Four patients with one PNI focus developed metastatic lymph node. One patient who had two and another who had three PNI foci had positive metastasis lymph nodes; while patients with four and five PNI foci developed no lymph node metastasis. This association was again found statistically insignificant (p=0.490) (Table 2). Lymph node metastasis was found in four patients with nerve size greater than 1mm and in two patients with nerve size less than 1mm. This association statistically was also insignificant (p=0.416).
Out of 7 patients who developed locoregional recurrence, 6 patients had PNI. This association was again found to be statistically significant (P=0.001) (Table 3). Out of these six patients, four had one focus of PNI, one had two and another one patient with three foci had recurrence. None of the patients of four and five foci developed recurrence. This association between PNI focality and recurrence was found to be statistically insignificant (p=0.535). Recurrence was found in four patients with nerve size greater than 1mm and in two patients with nerve size less than 1mm. This association was statistically not significant (p=0.672) (Table 4).
Table 3:
Table 4:
Discussion
Historically, the definition of PNI has changed over the last 35 years. Batsakis in 1985 defined PNI as tumor cells that invade in, around and through the nerves [4]. In 2009 Liebig, et al [4] stated that if the tumor cells were found in close proximity to the nerve and involved at least 33% of its circumference or if the tumor cells were found within any of the three layers of nerve sheath i.e., epineurium, perineurium or endoneurium, it should be considered as perineural invasion [4]. Versha, et al. [5] in a case series of 117 patients defined PNI as tumor cells that invades the perineurial space or epineurium [5]. PNI was initially thought to spread via perineurium or epineurium of the nerve sheath but this theory was later discarded as the ultra-scans of nerve sheath showed it as a highly selective barrier. Latest studies demonstrate that PNI occurs through various molecular interactions between tumor cells and nerve [6].
There is a wide variation in reported incidence of perineural invasion for oral squamous cell carcinoma, with reportage from as low as 2% to as high as 80% [7]. Various features of tumors seem to be related to the incidence of PNI. They include tumor thickness (depth of invasion), tumor differentiation and propensity for lymph node metastasis. Varsha, et al. [5] reported presence of perineural invasion in 40% cases. They didn’t find any particular association of frequency of perineural invasion with tumor size. However, they did find a higher incidence of PNI when the neck lymph nodes were positive for the disease [5]. Rahima B, et al. [8] in a retrospective study of 101 patients found a strong correlation between the depth of invasion by the tumor and PNI and stated that with increase in thickness of the tumor the chance of malignant cells to enter into the nerve fibers increases [8]. Strong relationship between PNI and lymph node metastasis has also been reported by multiple authors [9-12].
Incidence for PNI in our group of patients was found to be 22.03%. No significant was found with either age and gender. While most of the cases with PNI in our group were reported from tongue, site was not identified as statistically significant in our group of patients. Similarly grade and size of the tumor were also found insignificant variable for PNI though 10 of the 13 tumors were in T3 category. We did however find statistically significant relation between PNI and lymph node metastasis which concurs with literature mentioned above. Oral cavity tumors with PNI are prone to neck recurrence [13]. Nair, et al [14] in a retrospective analysis of 1524 patients found higher recurrence in neck node negative patients with PNI [14]. Size of the nerve involved in PNI is also assumed to have an association with recurrence. Aivazian, et al. [15] has shown that PNI in smaller nerves <1mm was not associated with recurrence whereas nerves >1mm in size was significantly associated with local recurrence (p=0.047) [15]. In our data, strong association was found between PNI and risk of recurrence. We however did not find any significant impact of the size of the nerve involved or number of tumor foci around the nerve upon the risk of recurrence.
In a study by Jardim, et al. [16] of 142 patients with SCC of tongue and floor of the mouth, the overall survival was negatively influenced by various variables including advance T stage and N stage, more than 2 clinically positive nodes, extra capsular spread, tumor thickness, PNI and LVI [16]. Similarly, most other studies have also shown PNI to different extent, associated with disease recurrence increased risk of regional and distant metastasis and overall decrease in 5-year survival [17, 18].
Conclusion
Majority of studies conclude that PNI is an independent prognostic factor for locoregional control of disease. It may also have an impact upon Overall and disease-free survival of the patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma.
To read more about this article...Open access Journal of Dentistry & Oral Health
Please follow the URL to access more information about this article
To know more about our Journals...Iris Publishers
No comments:
Post a Comment